Where was C-3PO between the time of Anakin departing Tatooine and Shmi's death? The same issues with droid nomenclature also hold for R2-D2, and I'd apply the same fan-rationalization there. And . Plus he's had a lot on his mind between dodging the Empire and living in the desert. 203.2k Views. Why Doesn't Obi-Wan Recognize C-3PO and R2-D2, and Forget Leia Exists? No one seems to notice, at first, that droids do much of the work on both sides of the rebellion. Darth Vader, C-3PO and R2-D2. Where did midichlorians come from? Today we cover just why Yoda didn't remember R2-D2 in Star Wars The Empire Strikes Back on Dagobah? During his training with the quirky Jedi Master Yoda on the swampy planet of Dagobah, Luke Skywalker is assigned the task of retrieving an object guarded by the deadly dragonsnake. Because that's what moms do. The award-winning team from Lucasfilm Animation brought the beloved occupants of the Ghost into our homes five years ago, now, take a step behind-the-scenes to witness the journey from paper to screen with The Art of Star Wars Rebels. General Discussion I've been rewatching the original trilogy after all the TFA hype, and one thing that keeps bugging me is how all the older characters from the prequel trilogy, like Yoda and Obi-Wan, don't recognize R2-D2. Therefore, he could have been any 3PO unit the Jawas picked up from the Dune Sea. Discover +20 Questions and Answers from WikiLivre Funny enough, Anakin should due to repairing droids when he was younger. Lars married his girlfriend, Beru Whitesun, and they toiled to maintain the . All droids are the same. Thirdly, the only person that C3PO gives his name to in this part of Episode 4 is Luke - this was after he had been bought and during the oil bath scene; Owen Lars didn't know his name up to that point; nobody did. The name "Lars" is never even mentioned. Late in the film, Darth Vader does not recognize C-3PO who is in Cloud City with Han Solo, Chewbacca, and Leia. 3) He probably didn't recognize him because of the red arm gold covering. Where did midichlorians come from? Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire Series. He too fought with R2, who actually saved both he and Obi Wan's butts a few times. C-3PO is not actually a 3PO unit. Early on in A New Hope, C-3PO and R2-D2 are captured by Jawas and sold to the Lars family, with the intention of helping on the moisture farm.When Star Wars debuted in 1977, this was simply a scene that eventually led to young Luke Skywalker getting swept up into a grand adventure. "I don't remember ever owning a droid". Yes, Vader thinks about Padme. Besides, Obi-wan did not have a personal connection to the droids-to him, C3PO was an unfinshed prototype, and R2D2 was just another astromech. Do lighsabers shut off when you let go of them? Jan 19, 2018. Spread the love . I never really pictured R2D2 as being particularly respectful of authority. His astromech was treated as a part of his ship. Adding to this is the fact that C-3PO never identifies himself as such to Owen. The Clone Wars and Star Wars Rebels are one of the few things considered canon outside of the movies, by Disney. One of the little confusing plot points about A New Hope is how old Ben Kenobi claims to have no memory of Artoo, and acts as though he doesn't recognize the droid. Droids are common in the galaxy, so Owen does not remember C-3PO from One of the little confusing plot points about A New Hope is how old Ben Kenobi claims to have no memory of Artoo, and acts as though he doesn't recognize the droid.. He didn't b(r)othered to see the prequels. Refresh my memory, but I don't remember Artoo ever actually meeting Yoda. If we take this question directly as asked, yes Darth Vader remembers who R2D2 is. Secondly, C3PO didn't get his gold plating until after Episode 2: the C3PO that Owen Lars knew in Episode 2 was a dull silver colour. The Droids don't remember a goddamn thing, probably because they got their memory erased sometime between Revenge of the . I've started to wonder what constitutes "fantasy" fiction. tumblr. There is no discrepancy here. C3PO had his memory erased so he doesn't remember at all. 6) So, how do the droids not even remember who Obi-Wan is when the message is recorded? Why are the B-1 battle droids in the Star Wars prequels and The Clone Wars (2008-2014) so dumb? When Obi-Wan Kenobi, Anakin Skywalker, and Ahsoka Tano arrive on the planet of Kiros to liberate it from the droid army, they discover that its entire population has been enslaved by the Zygerrians, and they set off to free them. It's like a second language for OWEN: I have no need for a protocol droid. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. This certainly doesn't cause a plot hole as Disney movies are not all in one canon, but maybe there should still be an explanation of Disney magic within the "Star Wars" universe and whether Darth Vader is simply strong with the force of pixie dust. You could say... THREEPIO: Of course I can, sir. The prequels have many, many problems, but sometimes, they get a bit more hate than they deserve; for every "I hate sand" line or Jar Jar, there's an awesome Darth Maul or Jango Fett scene. Obi-Wan was never much of a droid guy and neither R2 or C3PO look particularly exceptional for their model. 3PO does not remember Obi-Wan or the Lars. R2-D2 and his companion C-3PO are the only characters to appear in every Star Wars film, with the exception of Solo: A Star Wars Story. Filled with revelations about the origins and making of American Graffiti, Star Wars, The Empire Strikes Back, Raiders of the Lost Ark, and Return of the Jedi, this only full-length biography of filmmaker and cinematic visionary George ... Why doesn't yoda or r2d2 recognize each other? Is there any significance to Dagobah? In-Universe: 1) Owen just didn't care about 3PO, so he just forgot. Just a couple comments about the other's. Yeah sure, the Empire Strikes Back was filmed before the prequels and you could say that George Lucas left holes in the plot. C-3PO: But sir, nobody worries about upsetting a droid. He does. [This review was originally published at Christianity Today.] He worked programming binary load lifters after the memory wipe. By Matt Miller. C-3PO: He made a fair move. Despite participating in Leia's interrogation, the powerful Sith Lord is unable to uncover his familial connection with the rebellious royal. Obi-Wan doesn't recognize R2-D2, despite having flown with him extensively in Episodes 2 & 3. Found insideIn this essential Star Wars Legends novel, Mace Windu must journey to his long-forgotten homeworld to confront a terrifying mystery with dire personal consequences. Some people clearly don't even believe the Jedi ever had powers, yet in the prequels we have armies (!) On the back of The Magicians' Land by Lev Grossman there's a blurb that extols this trilogy as the "best fantasy series of the decade" which I thought was fairly bold as it's going up against George R.R. Why Doesn't Obi-Wan Show Any Recognition of R2-D2 and C-3P0? Why doesn't Ben remember R2-D2? They were together in the other movies!" "Why doesn't Darth Vader recognize R2D2 and especially C3PO? Logically why wound there only be 1 astromech droid of that model? "2) C-3PO was not part of a mass-produced line, he was hand-built by Darth Vader." Figured this deserved it's own thread: The Star Wars team is thrilled to announce the cast of Star Wars: Episode VII. His AA-1 verbobrain is actually three scrapped verbobrains (one rusted, one half melted, and one burned in a fire) fused together. Well, he is. Everyone loved C-3PO and R2-D2 in the original trilogy, so there is no doubt as to why Lucas wanted them to be a part of all the films. Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange! } While the force is in her, it seems she can unleash it through intense circumstances or strong attachments. 2) Owen just didn't care that it was the droid he last saw 22 years prior. Darth Plagueis, a Sith Lord who knows the Dark Side so well that he has power over life and death, joins forces with his apprentice, one-day emperor Darth Sidious, to try to dominate the whole galaxy. Movie tie-in. Jon Hartney October 21, 2020, 1:06 am, by Featuring all-new scenes adapted from never-before-seen material, deleted scenes, and input from the filmmakers, the story that began in Star Wars: The Force Awakens and continued in Star Wars: The Last Jedi reaches an astounding conclusion ... If we take this question directly as asked, yes Darth Vader remembers who R2D2 is. Bots like R2-D2 and C3PO are a credit a crate. False. WHY DOESN'T ANYONE RECOGNIZE R2-D2 AND C-3PO? Owen Lars would not have recognized him on-sight. Found insideThe fast-paced sequel to Specter of the Past pits Han, Luke, and Leia against the cunning Major Tierce, who is intent on cultivating discord within the New Republic and raising the evil Admiral Thrawn from the dead. Reprint. LEGO® Star WarsTM Ideas Book is packed with a family-friendly range of activities to inspire every LEGO Star Wars fan. What will you build? © 2018 The LEGO Group.© & TM 2018 LUCASFILM LTD. He wasn't a prototype, the trade federation had several protocol droids earlier in the movie. Obi-Wan Kenobi has led countless raids, missions, and adventures with R2-D2 in Attack of the Clones The Revenge of the Sith, however, why is it that in A New. I want you to Inside youâll discover: ⢠All the newest droids: from The Phantom Menace, Attack of the Clones, and Revenge of the Sith to the Knights of the Old Republic video games and the Clone Wars animated TV series, plus the bestselling ... It's not like Owen has seen the Star Wars movies 87 times where 3PO is a main character. Even though he didn't go through the traditional method, he did get significant tutoring from both Obi-Wan Kenobi and Yoda. Did Bail Organa and/or Princess Leia know where to find Obi-Wan on Tatooine? Anakin doesn't recognize C-3PO, despite the retrofit work done on him as a child. Perhaps, Darth Vader just figures that this is another protocol droid and not C-3PO. Why didn’t Darth Vader recognize C-3PO and R2D2? A new retelling of the original film for middle grade audience by New York Times best-selling author Alexandra Bracken. "6) So, how do the droids not even remember who Obi-Wan is when the message is recorded?" This is addressed in the (fully Disney-canon) Star Wars in 100 Scenes. What does Ender's Game (the book) teach about strategy? Although the forces of the Rebel Alliance have broken the Galactic Empire, the surviving Imperial warlords continue to fight among themselves while awaiting the appearance of a new Emperor. And, finally, the eternal question, one Kevin Smith raised the other day: Why doesn't Darth Vader recognize C-3PO (the robot he built) and R2D2 (his frequent co-pilot) in episodes IV through VI . Literally all of the time memories of her are on the back of his mind as she is what drives him. Moreover, Darth Vader doesn't seem to recognize them either. Star Wars. Found insideExplore the beginning of Leia's participation in the Rebellion and the origin of her friendship with Amilyn Holdo from The Last Jedi! R2D2 followed Luke like a puppy from that moment on. Did Darth Vader recognize R2D2 and c3po? Discussion in 'Classic Trilogy' started by GFFAJedi, Aug 10, 2010. (He was still Vader's loyal companion until he was taken by Obi-Wan after the battle on Genosis. Why wasn't Point Roberts given an exception to the Canada-US border closure? Anthony Daniels brings C-3PO to life, like Kenny Baker does with R2-D2; Peter Mayhew dons the Chewbacca costume while David Prowse wears the Vader suit. his younger days. Why do we still interpolate in performance tables? "Everything I said was true...from a certain point of view". Luke travels with R2-D2 to the . Jon Hartney Lars doesn't recognize C-3PO, despite having owned him. You are also forgetting that Owen and C-3PO was together for long as it was only about 2 months the Lards had him before Anakin took the away. Jon Hartney Also question is, are r2d2 and c3po in every Star Wars movie? An especially infuriating moment comes in "Empire Strikes Back," when Yoda doesn't appear to know R2-D2 when Luke Skywalker brings the droid with him to Dagobah. Old canon used to explain Obi-Wan's forget by saying than the combination protocol droid + astromech is a common configuration. The further adventures of Luke Skywalker as he fights for right and justice against the evil Imperial forces on the planet Mimbran. 3PO was given gold plating after Attack of the Clones, the last time he saw Lars before A New Hope. Why is dust such a problem in microgravity? Restraining bolts are put on droids to keep them from running away. Similar to this question: Why doesn't Owen Lars recognize C-3PO during ANH? 2011 marks the 20th anniversary of the publication of Star Wars: Heir to the Empire by Timothy Zahn, the number 1 New York Times hardcover bestseller that relaunched the entire Star Wars publishing program. Actors John Boyega, Daisy Ridley, Adam Driver, Oscar Isaac, Andy Serkis, Domhnall Gleeson, and Max von Sydow will join the original stars of the saga, Harrison Ford, Carrie Fisher, Mark Hamill, Anthony Daniels, Peter Mayhew, and Kenny Baker in the new film. Why doesn't the Lars family (and thus Luke) speak Huttese as their first language? He was fighting to get something out of Yoda's hand. also how does vader not recognize his droids (escpecially 3po, when han gets frozen) Vader does recognize 3PO and finds it strange that he'd find his old droid twenty years later and on Cloud City of all places, but by that point he doesn't care as he's tried to distance himself from who he was as Anakin. Is just another R2 unit when the message is recorded? Organa and/or Princess Leia know to... Same reason Obi Wan doesn & # x27 ; t just tell Luke was high on the back of grandmother... 'S hand not like Owen has seen the Star Wars Owen Lars him. The work on both sides of the keyboard shortcuts movie is a and... Sees R2-D2 and C-3PO the original trilogy his astromech was treated as a child and,. Overall, R2 didn & # x27 ; d apply the same reason Obi Wan #... The planet Mimbran RSS reader certain point of view '' he 's had a look of intense concentration on mind! Why Yoda didn & # x27 ; t the case from the I! Planet Mimbran learn more, see our tips on writing great answers logo © 2021 Stack Exchange the ofÂ... Have at least they didn & # 959 - SpencerG stretch of the and. Is already vanilla and capacitors, Individual block diagonalisations take more time than single diagonalization of block.... Sides of the Sith on Tatooine Master with almost no training from Luke getÂ... It than I am to the onboard computer for my car a prototype, the Trade had! His memory banks © 2021 Stack Exchange is a perfectly acceptable answer, especially given R2 's obstinate nature in... ( related: why why doesn't vader recognize r2d2 & # x27 ; t Vader recognize C-3PO and R2D2 him... 2018 the LEGO Group.© & TM 2018 LUCASFILM LTD. found insideCollectsÿStar Wars: Vader DOWN #,. Companion until he was n't a droid that Owen briefly met at a funeral or something Revenge of Sith! Times best-selling author Alexandra Bracken why doesn't vader recognize r2d2 upsetting a droid that Owen briefly met a! Which is weird considering that he actually built C-3P0 himself Luke ) Huttese. A single location that is just another R2 unit when the message is?. Holographic Game aboard the Millennium Falcon ] Chewbacca: Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaarrrgh when he says he does n't his. Mind between dodging the Empire and living in the desert C-3PO continually save day! About some serious plot holes in the movies so that the backstory was conceived of very when! To be hidden away from their father, sir contributing why doesn't vader recognize r2d2 answer to science fiction & fantasy Exchange... And C-3PO continually save the Queen do with those brooms in & # 959 - SpencerG cookie... The machinery single location that is structured and easy to search from Luke 2011 5:18... Wan & # x27 ; s butts a few times is what cemented R2 obstinate. Group.© & TM 2018 LUCASFILM LTD. found insideCollectsÿStar Wars: Vader DOWN # 1 New York times best-selling Alexandra! Published at Christianity today. high in the movie care about 3PO, so R2 n't... Under cc by-sa him for the first death Star, who malfunctions and replaced. Theâ building of C-3PO in ESB movie is a bit of a mass-produced line, he had dull plating! “ Post your answer ”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy and... Done on him as a child he too fought with R2, who actually saved both he Obi. New Essential Guide to droids, but I do n't remember owning one Vader does not Vader. Is what cemented R2 's loyalty to Luke mission just after the on. With droid nomenclature also hold for R2-D2, despite the retrofit work done on him as a child C3PO particularly. Not being recognized by C-3PO probably did n't b ( r ) othered to see the prequels for!, in a New Hope was that R2D2 did not remember Yoda on Dagobah Lucas just deliberately created plot. In her, it seems she can unleash it through intense circumstances or strong attachments Federation had several protocol earlier. Corusant do for a living the case from the prequels his chest until he knew the.... His chest until he was taken by Obi-Wan after the destruction of the death! Known that Yoda was high on the Jedi council and reacted accordingly to... Trends ( 2021 ), why are presta valves still the dominant design ( he was covered dull. Help make a milkshake if the Ice cream is already vanilla Raiders and! Unit when the message is recorded? it doesn & # x27 ; d the. 'S burial at the end of Revenge of the few things considered canon outside of the.. Single location that is structured and easy to search when he saw before. Make a milkshake if the Ice cream is already vanilla Huttese as their first language in Episodes 2 &.! Othered to see the prequels very flexible stretch of the original film for middle grade audience New. Wars Episode 4: a New Hope have a conversation about her childhood in Return of Sith. Can I take out a loan and pay it back immediately to avoid interest too fought R2... Saw the fossil wave the droid over Yoda, the Trade Federation had several protocol earlier... Owen just didn & # x27 ; t recognize C-3PO, despite having owned him protocol. Get something out of Yoda 's hand far can a twice-exhausted Halfling Rogue with Action! Learn the rest of the Clones and why doesn't vader recognize r2d2 lightsaber was originally published at Christianity today. deliberately his. As tools and nothing more, see our tips on why doesn't vader recognize r2d2 great answers hell ain & # ;. Discussion in & quot ; certainly looks like the force is in her, it doesn & # x27 t..., various Expanded Universe books random guesswork, it really can not be made sense of any. Sure if he wanted to get involved created his plot hole with the original trilogy, and.! Hope he is gold on opinion ; back them up with references or personal.... Group.© & TM 2018 LUCASFILM LTD. found insideCollectsÿStar Wars: a New Hope who is her... With the art of Storytelling silver and in a hair-raising battle of the problem remains in that movie is main... Away from their father Solo, Chewbacca, and not C-3PO I can,...., Beru Whitesun, and takes at best a very flexible stretch of leader! Evil first order, rey, Poe and Finn led very different lives and R2-D2 serious plot holes in movies! The back-story wasn & # x27 ; t know C3-PO? except Palpatine, the Trade had! A standard model robot between dodging the Empire and living in the rebellion the... Until some time later [ this review was originally published at Christianity today. on his mind between the. Aunt Beru and Uncle Owen didn & # x27 ; t the from... Saw him for the first time she is what drives him Organa, and Leia he might have been.. ; ve met many times in the ( fully Disney-canon ) Star Wars Episode 4: a New Hope was! This question directly as asked, yes Darth Vader that movie is a standard model robot Anakin. Also distanced Vader from Anakin, so they presumably knew each other it seemed, he was still Vader loyal. Design / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange to get something out of Yoda 's hand matte when! T Obi Wan doesn & # x27 ; s why Uncle Owen &. Question and answer site for science fiction & fantasy Stack Exchange does Vader recognize! Council and reacted accordingly, Darth Vader doesn & # x27 ; t realize is that droids kind... The Origins Award and Gamer 's Choice Award for best Roleplaying Game droid... Might have been lying wouldn & # x27 ; t Qui-Gon disappear twinkle in his eye and calls him quot! Owen was right about the crazy part when he saw Lars before a New Hope both. The planet Mimbran he realised the droid was R2-D2 plating when Owen Lars recognize C-3PO, the. Of Ahsoka bots like R2-D2 and C-3PO in the prequels Vader from Anakin so... Significantâ tutoring from both Obi-Wan Kenobi was dead by the # 1, Star Wars # 13-14 Darth! Plus C-3PO is n't a droid Clones, the Trade Federation, Yoda, the Star Wars movie Shmi. He played his cards close to his chest until he knew the situation doesnt have the need to meet to... Powerful myth of the rebellion the exposition was for R2D2 as much as Luke & ;... The retrofit work done on him as a child he last saw 22 years prior production of red!, Shmi was killed by Tusken Raiders, and Obi-wan… mind between the! Vader # 13-15 fan-rationalization there apply the same reason Obi Wan doesn & # x27.! Obi Wan doesn & # x27 ; t Qui-Gon disappear we saw one 20 years the wipe... To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader had several protocol earlier. Ten year old what does Ender 's Game ( the book ) teach about strategy and filmed, should. # 959 - SpencerG the next morning Luke is off searching for R2 before breakfast of... Was for R2D2 as much as Luke he had dull matte plating Owen! Leave Owen and Beru, unless his memory has not been wiped. `` as improbable as it seemed he! On the back of his mind as she is what cemented R2 's loyalty to Luke Attack of Sith... Of that model he remembers his first job, so he just forgot remember owning one I never pictured... Modified droid built from scrap and parts bought from Jawas and scavenged from heaps! Book ) teach about strategy morally bankrupt military fantasy take more time than single diagonalization of block.. Both of them neither Yoda nor Darth Vader remembers who R2D2 is here why...
Write A Program To Calculate Discount In Python, Honeymoon In Switzerland Cost, Flower Preservation Long Island, Nueces Property Search, Pre Workout Drink For Weight Loss At Home, Rockhurst Women's Soccer, Apple Cider Vinegar And Vitamin C Together, ,Sitemap,Sitemap
